Pre-made cakes available in our case! open daily! We sell dry ice
Walk through about ordering a cake with us
How to Place a Dessert Order 🍰
1️⃣ Pick Your Date
We typically need 3–4 days’ notice for custom orders, but if you’re short on time, we’ll do our best to make it work if we are ahead of schedule
2️⃣ Choose Your Size
(Check out our cake size options below.)
3️⃣ Select Your Ice Cream Flavor
Most popular: Vanilla, Oreo, Cookie Dough, Mint Chip, Peanut Butter Cup.
We rotate 44+ flavors — if we have it in stock, we can use it!
4️⃣ Cake Type
White, Chocolate, or All Ice Cream (no cake layer).
5️⃣ Design Style
Birthday, Chocolate Decadent, Rainbow Sprinkles, or themed designs.
Please see below for examples of drawings we can do. These are available at an additional cost. If you have a very specific design in mind, please attach it below or see our 'Cake Gallery' tab.
(We draw in buttercream only.)
6️⃣ Wording
Tell us what you’d like written on the cake + color of writing.
Cakes we typically keep on hand for last minute pick up
🍰 Vanilla ice cream w chocolate cake
🍰 Oreo ice cream w white or chocolate cake
🍰 Cookie dough ice cream w white or chocolate cake
🍰 Peanut butter cup w chocolate cake
🍰 Mint chip w chocolate cake
🍰 Strawberry w white cake
⚠️ Please let us know upfront if you need dairy-free, gluten-free, or other special options.
📩 Any questions? Email us — we’re happy to help! Bcreamerycakes@comcast.net
Cakes are completely customizable!
Mini
Mini
The mini cake serves 2-4 people.
$21.99 base price
4x4 rectangle
Small
Mini
The small cake serves 6-8 people.
$33.99 base price
4x8 rectangle
Medium
The medium serves 10-12 people.
$42.99 base price
6x8 rectangle
*New* 7' Round
The 7in round serves 10-12 people.
$42.99 base price
Roll Cake
The roll cake serves 10-12 people.
$42.99 base price
Cake rolled in ice cream with a fudge outside
10' Round
The 10 inch round serves
16-18 people.
$57.99 base price
Quarter Sheet
Quarter sheet serves 20-24 people.
$70.99 base price
8x12 rectangle
Quarter-Small
Quarter-small serves 28-32 people.
$88.99 base price
8x16 rectangle
Quarter-Medium
Quarter-medium serves 32-36 people.
$99.99 base price
8x18 rectangle
Half Sheet
Half Sheet
Half Sheet serves 40-48 people.
$130.99 base price
12x16 rectangle
Discover the Best Ice Cream Pies at Batavia Creamery $33.99
Turtle Ice Cream Pie
Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie
Turtle Ice Cream Pie
This dessert features a delectable chocolate crust, topped with Pralines 'N' Cream Ice Cream, a layer of rich caramel, and a fudgy border. To add the finishing touches, it is garnished with a chocolate drizzle and pecans. It's a mouth-watering treat that's sure to satisfy any sweet tooth!
serves 8
Oreo Ice Cream Pie
Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie
Turtle Ice Cream Pie
For a delicious dessert, start with a chocolate crust and top it off with Oreo ice cream, a fudge layer, and a whipped cream border. For the finishing touches, garnish with chocolate drizzle and crushed Oreos. Enjoy!
serves 8
Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie
Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie
Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie
For a delicious dessert, start with a chocolate crust and add Cookie Dough Ice Cream. Top it off with Fudge and a whipped cream border. For a finishing touch, garnish with chocolate drizzle and Chips Ahoy cookies. Enjoy!
serves 8
Grasshopper Ice Cream Pie
Charlie Brown Ice Cream Pie
Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie
This dessert features a delicious chocolate crust layered with Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream, topped with fudge, and a whipped cream border. To add some extra flair, it's garnished with a chocolate drizzle and Andes mint chips.
serves 8
Charlie Brown Ice Cream Pie
Charlie Brown Ice Cream Pie
Charlie Brown Ice Cream Pie
Our peanut butter cup ice cream is nestled on a bed of rich fudge, peanut butter cups, and all resting on top of a perfectly baked graham cracker crust. Topped with a generous pour of our decadent peanut butter sauce, this treat is finished with a whipped border and garnished with Reese's cups. The finishing touch? A drizzle of both chocolate and peanut butter that is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings.
serves 8
*NEW* PB Oreo Overload
Charlie Brown Ice Cream Pie
Charlie Brown Ice Cream Pie
A rich chocolate crust, loaded with creamy peanut butter Oreo ice cream. It’s topped with a thick layer of peanut butter, a fluffy whipped border, and finished off with a mix of Oreos and peanut butter cups, all drizzled with chocolate and peanut butter sauces. A perfect treat for anyone who loves a little extra
serves 8
